I thought the scene where what's her name is exploring those ruins was surprisingly evocative for jjabrams star wars sequel but yeah that was like two seconds of the movie but I could see it being sort of ineffable experience if you were a kid.
anybody ever watch any brian eno interviews? because I think he's hella good guy at creating atmosphere/mystery and doesn't seem inauthentic but he's hella articulate and seems like he could verbalize his entire thought process behind making music if he needed to?? Like he seems like the only weirdmusic dude ever to be that way/not acting on some instinct/impossible thought process
RE Force Awakens, Yeah I thought literally in same beats, that the beginning scene was for a moment nice. The rest of the movie was pretty much JJ Abrhamas [sic]/modern movie stuff.
Im just gonna quote dat brian eno bit there as a reminder cos if ragnar likes him a bit then maybe i should give him more of a serious go. i'm like okay with his thoughts in general and interviews but it's nothing special afai seen.
It makes me think of my friend that gripes about how The Force Awakens was treated. Like in his mind, Star Wars as a setting invoked very specific feelings of discovery and nuance the very first time he watched it. Because of that, he was especially offended at how the newest movie never really tried to explore anything, takes risks, or introduce any new concepts. (He was also really into the narrative brought on by the previous novels that were "third trilogy canon" before George Lucas was bought out, but whenever he tries to explain the "plot" of it to me, I just see it as even more contrived and arbitrary than ANYTHING Abrhams could have come up with. Sure it means a lot to HIM, but in my mind I just see it as his own imagination reading far more into the text than was actually there... Despite me never actually READING the text firsthand)
TFA never really bothered me none, mainly because I always saw Star Wars as something not made for any one specific person, but rather deliberately appeals to what the largest number of people can connect and identify with. I don't think that's a bad goal for science fiction to have, but I can't help but be offended personally by how well it was accomplished. I always look to science fiction to be deliberately challenging to my own ideas and perceptions, and Star Wars constantly disappoints me at every level for failing to rise to that challenge. (The only vaguely interesting idea that setting ever offered was the idea of how "spirituality" might evolve parallel to technology if left going for thousands and thousands of years, but even that notion is so distilled and contrived that I find it even more insulting as a premise)
I see what you are hinting there mate. ;-) I think the problem is that sometimes nerds and really all ppl don't really know for sure what makes a good media... like what are the parts that make a movie specifically good in it's own specific way... but they can at least instinctually or generally feel when something is done right when they experience it... well, at least some portion of experiencers can.
for example, original trilogy certainly has some good shit going on in there (i won't go in too much about it here), but that doesn't mean the books got it right etc... just like how you vibed ur dude's take on the books.
it's very hard to articulate what makes a good movie (at least, what made that specific media in past so good as it is). I've gotten pretty good at it /to myself specifically/ but try as i might, i may never really convincingly explain what makes shit good as it is. it's also really wordy and cumbersome sometimes to analyze and explain out the specific parts, which already gives it a disavantage of " doesn't sound intuitive, ergo it's not correct most likely " - bias. for example, i'm already messing that part up!!!!!!!!! eff my life. *SPIT*
and yeah i sorta think SW (star wars or salt world...) was simultaenously a Indiana Jones - type of action movie, with some strong esthetic-exploration-mystery type of elements in there. Indiana Jones meets Dune or 2001. it does the latter better than dune or aliens etc tho, that was part of the strong draw of SW for me as a kid.