Maybe because internet grudges are retarded and pretty much anyone is welcome here as long as they can behave

I agree with Moriason as well, I mean, in real life you don't just:
"Hey man, remember me?"
"Yeah; you punched me in the face, stole my girlfriend, and made all my friends think i was a loser."
"Oh come on, that was YEARS ago, lets be friends, just forget that stuff."
It just doesn't work that way.

That said, however, this is a forum and I believe you should at least give the guy a chance to fuck it up again...if thats what is to happen. The worst that can happen is that everyone hates him because he is still a moron and he gets banned. Otherwise, who knows, he really might have changed. I'm sure he isn't worse than some of our members in G&D, anyway.

you don't really just get to be retarded and then come back and act like nothing ever happened why don't members ever seem to get that

Maybe you aren't retarded now, but all we have to go on champ is what has happened.

I honestly would think this to be a SIMPLE CONCEPT but people never seem to understand it when they want to come back and bitch that we all hold grudges and shit.