I second the Castlevania games (as usual :\).
Castlevania Portrait of Ruin (I actually did not like Dawn of Sorrow but I don't think I gave it a fair shot and it is probably the better game)
Yes Dawn of Sorrow is, in many ways, the better game. It's just that, Portrait of Ruin had so much potential for being much better than Dawn of Sorrow, but they just didn't use that potential to it's full extent. For example, a lot of the level designs lacked. They just felt like they were shoved in only to make the game larger. They could've been more creative with the stages themselves, like at least give the Egypt stage a bit of a heat effect (like the ones in Sonic & Knuckles) or make the London (or London-esque) stages more than just a bakery and butchery with an occasional chapel. Don't get me wrong though, I'm not saying Portrait of Ruin is bad, I still love it a lot, but in comparison to Dawn of Sorrow it lacks somewhat.