Oh they love it when people have funny and articulate dissenting opinions. That post would go over great there. The userbase only appears unanimous if you look at the threads for a single game; everyone who doesn't like the game will just ignore the thread. And since we're on the subject I've even read SB people directly criticize Kojima and call him a hack, without anyone feeling attacked and sticking up for their beloved Kojima-sensei, as would doubtlessly happen in plenty of games discussion spaces.
BUT I know exactly what you mean about trying to find something interesting because a lot of the threads are just total mundanities. e.g. Star Wars talk. It was sort of unpleasant to reread my last post and realize that passively going over those mundanities is literally what I consider "nonpoisonous media discussion". That's how I get my entertainment news. I probably shouldn't recommend forums on the basis of my own total disconnection from reality.
To all those reading this, I think these threads are pretty fun afternoon reading:
https://selectbutton.net/t/games-nobody-learned-anything-from/1816https://selectbutton.net/t/grotesque-videogames/1408https://selectbutton.net/t/strangest-coolest-rpg-mechanics/3393https://selectbutton.net/t/romm-comm-tuum/7568 - thecatamites reviews romantic comedies
https://selectbutton.net/t/dark-archie-timeline/5519 - thecatamites talks about the archie series
https://selectbutton.net/c/king-of-posters/go/12 - this entire subforum is good if you like collecting recurring images throughout the history of games
https://selectbutton.net/t/compelling-trash-action/9962https://selectbutton.net/t/videogame-things-you-think-about-a-lot/8689...but if they're not your kind of thing, I maintain no responsibility. You didn't even hear my name, got it?
Overall, they have a diverse enthusiastic userbase so they're at their best when they're working together to gather examples of interesting things from a wide array of games. If you ask them for recommendations, they're fantastic. They're at their worst when you read the threads about a single game, where everyone will agree circuitously. Or ask for help with a frustrating section.
While there is certainly no better home for d*mptop than this one, seeing as it's such a salt world thing through and through, I do wish I knew some way to bring eyes here... 300 pages of screenshots, text and video devoted to experiences that otherwise go unexplored - it's like a grand unexcavated mausoleum of the gaming artform.