There are lots of different things to talk about in this area and it is kind of hard to avoid conflating them all, so i'm gonna dive in with some bullet points
yeah i think i agree that there are aspects of things that you can appreciate despite the whole of the thing it came from not being so amazing. almost every video game is an example of this, and it is the reason why i guess alot of us are compelled to play rpg after rpg despite these games being largely terrible. if you are creative, then it is even useful because you can latch on to those little moments in things (which were probably even accidental, most of the time) and let them grow in your own mind.
i remember REALLY liking this one particular shot in the movie jacob's ladder. that isn't a good movie, but this shot made new york look a way that it had never really looked to me before. the picture i was looking at looked like it was taken in a reality just tiny little to the left of ours, very similar, but the things which inhabited it were strange and eerie. the film's atmosphere in the early stages kind of encouraged the eerie reading but my memory and enjoyment of that particular shot has next to nothing to do with the film, and it's use in this particular badly made movie doesn't diminish how interesting it was to me. this particular feeling is the same reason i liked the silent hill games. they are so badly made most of the time but they occasionally tap into something very interesting which i find fascinating, creepy and cool.
basically, i think yes you can get unexpected things out of everything and while there is totally a need for discerning taste, just because something racks up a few more points on the crappy side, it doesn't destroy all of the interesting ideas involved. even if those ideas are accidental, or just the indications of something that was never explored.
i have been working on my bad habit of immediately checking wikipedia/etc after i read a book, watch a movie or tv show, or listen to music or play a game. i don't want to experience something then immediately become saturated with information of who made it and how and when and why it was made.
i'm not saying understanding the context of, uh, art is not important but i think i am destroying my ability to think critically about things by having all of that information immediately served up to me, taking on the opinions i happen to agree with most, and then shelving whatever experience it happens to be as 'finished'.
knowing too much about the creator of something can totally ruin it for you as well, yeah. you'll get some big surprises sometimes (oh you know that musician you love? he's a racist prick) which are probably worth losing your love for something over (i am not sure if my little brother knows who john mayer really is, and i have been considering giving him the low down on that trashbag). however there is other stuff like reading how david lynch once made a comment about liking ronald reagan. david lynch has been kind of a big guy for me the past few months so i am sorry for overusing him as an example but yeah, david lynch as a person does seem a little...something. it's a bit too easy to read some of his stuff as very conservative american pride stuff (has anyone seen the straight story? it put me in a bad mood with david lynch for weeks. it is so fucking bad). but david lynch is nuts, right? and he's said other stuff like republicans should all move to another country (allegedly - and really all of this is just hearsay crap from the internet anyway), so whatever, his politics are confusing, and really, totally irrelevant because his movies are too fucking interesting to dismiss them over that boring shit.
the straight story is kind of an issue but i don't know. i have more to say, but i want to see what other people say to see if i am making any sense first.
this is easy. don't do the same stuff all the time! if you love anything, that passion is just gonna dwindle if you stick it on the lappy just for five minutes while you eat your microwaved rice.
also, it becomes so much easier to get enthralled by the surface of things this way, i think. my little brother had some mock the week type shit on tv last week and i came in and asked him 'why are you watching this crap' and he said he liked the atmosphere it creates and...nah. i'm not joining in with that.
taking a break!!!