Damn those old Nintendo Power covers were cool though I grew up thinking were they clay, cg, really good drawings??? and it turns out they were this weird mixed-media shit that not like nobody does mixed media anymore but the Nintendo Power covers had the GRAIN of early 90's on their side really made it difficult to tell how someone made the images
this is a bit later than you're referring to but the nintendo power issue about pokemon stadium (i have it at my house for some reason still but i can't find a pic online) had this cover (or maybe it was art in the article??) where the pokemon did look like clay even though they were cg (i guess????) and i'm pretty sure most other covers were like this too. this is what i immediately thought of when you said clay because they never quite looked CG but they didn't exactly look like anything else either and it was always very weird!
i really miss the days when nintendo power determined the bulk of my video game purchases. it sounds weird from today's standpoint but i mean nowadays i don't even hear about anything but the main games coming out (call of duty again: this time it's serious). i mean with the internet i should hear about MORE games but instead i just hear less!!! at least with GW if something like deadly premonition comes along i'm aware of it but nintendo power would have a fucking list of almost every game coming out for their systems the following month. i'm not aware of games other than halo call of duty w/e coming out unless i am in a store and happen to see them or unless it's something like ghost trick where yeah it's not one of the huge franchises but there's enough excitement around it to have seen it on joystiq.
but when i was a kiddo it wasn't like this at all, i mean you still knew what the big games were because nintendo paid more attention to pokemon or donkey kong or mario but they reviewed everything. i can't remember the name but there was some game where you played a big fat redneck (probably named bubba) and you played all these redneck themed mini games and i remember seeing it and going "jesus this looks like the worst game" but i still liked the fact that nintendo had a mini review on it! i wanted an n64 because of nintendo power but i didn't want it because of mario 64 or OoT, i wanted it for snowboard kids 2. because i read a little feature on it and it sounded hella cool. and it WAS hella cool!!! i also got legend of the river king because of nintendo power, which is a game i still really like even though there's nothing too special about it (except fishing rpg....) and i got revelations: the demon slayer and idk i can't remember if the shadowgate thing was in nintendo power or another magazine but what i'm saying applies to other magazines too though nintendo power seemed to have weirder games
the point is if i had grown up with the internet as it is right now i never would have bought any of these games because i wouldn't have even been aware of them. yet i'm always painfully aware when a new halo or call of duty comes out despite the fact that i don't play either one. and video game magazines right now, from what i've seen of the ones that still exist, have gone this way too.