The song choice really dampened the experience for me, but overall, I love the menu. This feeling is heightened because I rejoice to see someone program something that's more than decent in RM2k/3.
I get a real Final Fantasy 9 vibe from the menu, though that's not a bad thing. I do have some minor things to mention, though:
- the cursor repeat speed seems way too fast. It looks like the player would often accidentally choose the wrong thing if he's hurrying through the menu and does little more than tap the directional keys. I'd have to play it myself to judge it for certain, but I remember having a problem with this kind of thing in Final Fantasy Origins, so the concern is legitimate.
- the menu skins, while nice, seem...unnecessary, and I'd wager a guess that you had to create a good seven times as many files in order to implement them. Personally, I'd choose a color that suited my project and stick with a single theme, but that's just me. This is less of a concern and more of an opinion, though.
Other than that, I can't really find anything wrong with it. It looks awesome. I hope to one day see "Project Kangaroo" take flight, as I'm genuinely interested now.
Thanks for the response. Regarding the song choice, I knew that some people would be switched off by it. I chose it simply in the spirit of Final Fantasy XIII which releases this next week and figured it would click with people. I myself don't really like RnB too much, but most of the other videos either have some hardcore rock, classical piano (which I admit I use often), or something else. I figured I'd mix it up a bit.
About the cursor speed, I agree that it does look fast on in the video, but you really would have to play it first hand as you suggested to really get the feel for it. The video does make it look a bit faster than it really is due to the loss in frame rate, but I may even make a cursor speed option somewhere.
As for the menu skins, they are essentially unnecessary, but it's just something that has stuck with me and I think gives my project a bit of an identity in terms of it's menu. Originally the menu started with just Violet and Classic Blue, but in the end I decided to put some more diverse skins in there just to give people more of a choice. But again, you are right that they aren't essential, but as long as they aren't hurting the game I'm fine with them being there. If file size ever does get out of control, which I don't see it doing, then I may look into cutting some of them down.
But again - thanks a lot for the reply. It's great to see some positive responses about the menu. It's taken a lot of my time and effort.
