I'd think I'd be wrong too, but that's what happened. My mainsite was never used, and my site was much more active when we instead focused on community events and shit.
We've had a Finished Games board for ages and how many of them have almost no (or none at all!!!) replies?
That's the thing, you don't even have
staff posting in them so why are members going to join and do the same?
You need people there running and maintaining the site who actually give a fuck about the content, rather than just running the site in the background. Like, get some game reviewers to review any completed games posted. Or at least do a feature on new games every month or something.
And shit look where your completed games board is - it's a tiny subforum of a board called Advertising in a section that is in with the "dead crap". Why isn't it even in the creativity section \o_O/