http://kotaku.com/5981171/?post=56956833
I know I know kotaku is dumb
I just want to know what you guys think?
I've never played the game but watching that video of the character immediately made me think "She's racist?, I guess?"
IDK if saying 'crunk' and 'badonadonk' is racist. Though I admittedly have a special dislike of the word 'badonadonk' for its use in one of the worst songs I've ever heard.
Changing her might fuck up her character, and continuity. Even if she is racist, which is debatable, technically, could you just say she's a 'good person but problematic character'. and, like leave it at that? because people like this do exist.
This is coming from someone who's never played the game because they did not find the first game very fun.
idk. the character's lines just seem like bad writing - sensational faux-hyper derivative writing by clueless career gamers. in this context, I think "verbal blackface" is a stretch. I mean, the first thing I think of when there's a QuIrKy white person saying badonkadonk is ellen degeneres. ellen uses language like that as jokes on her show, and the idea is that the jokes are supposed to be ellen making fun of herself and how uh I guess UN-HIP she is. that's the intent, whether or not it's successful idc. I don't know if there's ever a reason given for why this character talks like that, maybe she's supposed to have DID or some other mental disorder, but I guess there's similarly supposed to be humor in the way a young qUiRkY white girl uses outdated hip hop lingo from the 00s.
the guy arguing is probably unknowingly racist going by his comments. the character itself isn't
necessarily racist, that's definitely a stretch (DID, picked up the lingo from someone of unknown ethnicity, many other possibilities). whether or not the inclusion of such a character in the game is racist or damaging, that's a more difficult question that I don't know if I can answer. it was definitely not a great idea, but we've already covered that
I remember kind of liking that scene with her in the trailer where she giddily blows something up, but also being apprehensive about it probably being some kind of awful tank girl pastiche. and yeah apparently it is, it's just taking some poor impressions from tank girl and mashing them with some looney tunes and jar jar binks
edit: can only have a nonsexual female char in game if she reaffirms the truth and justice of macho white male gamer south park humor