I keep wanting to say something to OddButInteresting (not that interesting actually), but I know that I'll just end up calling him a complete tool and he'll probably just start talking about the finer points of Santa With Muscles.
That shit died at least three pages ago. Your chat is dry. These shallow attempts at wit are near unbearable to behold.
Oh, and correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't you the David Lynch enthusiast? The only Lynchflick I've seen is
Dune, and it was fucking
dire. It had its occassional redeeming moments, but I'm not going to waste any time listing the finer points of why it's a complete and utter failure; as an adaptation, and as a film in its own right. But as a starting point: if you're greeted in the first shot by the worst chromakey work in cinema history, it's fairly conclusive how the rest of the film's going to present itself. Nice costumes, though.
However, I'm not one to judge a person by counting the warts on their face. I've been meaning to give
Blue Velvet a shot for some time.
By the way: I believe you not only didn't state whether you'd even seen Watchmen, but in the event that you had, you didn't elaborate upon why you loathe it so either (at least that's what I managed to glean from the inferences in your earlier post).
This isn't a counter-attack, by the way. I'm just hoping to engage you, as a fellow cinephile, in an intelligent critical dialogue.
I'm pretty impressed that some of you people are so serious into this book. If it were a series or something it would make sense to me, but given that it's relatively short it just seems so crazy that you can list the moments where characters smoke. Wow.
I just have a good memory for this sort of thing. Plus, I read the whole thing from back-to-front a week or so ago, in preparation for the film. I've also occassionally read random chapters over the past three years, so I've got a pretty in-depth understanding of the material.
Or I'm just a nerd, which I'm more than comfortable with

.