This is coming from a frequent RMXP user too (See Kryberia). I think people should quit making their whiney assumptions and sit back and see what people make. No I am not an enterbrain fanboy, I just don't like the negativity. There's nothing worse than making a game in the MOST RECENT rpg maker and then someone going "I would play this if it wasn't made in RMXP". You are effectively closing your minds to what is potentially a much more efficient way of making RPGs.
Give it a chance.
I agree with you on that. I really do hate people not even giving RMXP games a chance, especially with games like Cell Chamber. Most people don't even play them because they either don't look good in terms of mapping and SPECIAL FX, or they see the default battle system and are turned off by it.
But the problem is with RMVX, people CAN'T make anything. You're so limited because of the massive changes they've done. You'll have to remake all of your character sets, chipsets, etc. Basically, if you have an old project that you want to import over because of some of the new features, you can't. Enterbrain basically said "Eh fuck the guys on 2K, 2K3, and XP. If they want their old project on here, too bad. They have to use our RTP."
Now that they've ruled out all of the old RPG Makers, they're now aiming towards new people, and people who want to make something original. The other problem though is the RM scene RARELY comes out with any graphically original games. I can't even name 5 unique looking games on RMXP. Even now, after 3 years, RMXP is still trying to catch up with RM2K and RM2K3 in terms of content. How long will it take RMVX to catch up with XP or 2K/2K3?
I can give it a chance, but I'll be waiting a few years.