RETURN FROM THE DEAD!
Yeah, never played this, but I was wondering if this is MMO is as bad as everyone makes it seem. Its apparently horrible and shouldn't be touched.
It's not nearly as bad as people say it is. Even with all of it's flaws and problems it's way better than most free MMORPGs. While the content is still rather lacking the PvP is FUN and the PvE isn't that bad either. There's a serious lack of quests after about level 45 (max level being 80) but if you make it to the end game you've got two tiers of raiding. The gameplay is a lot more fun than the usual passive wait for cooldowns style all other MMORPGs seem to use.
There's also big plans for PvP system (pvp levels, criminal system etc) coming and some new zones for more quests and dungeons, but Funcom is taking their time with them (way too long...).
But if I had to recommend one of the big three (WoW, WAR and AoC) I'd currently go with WAR.