Man, I seriously seriously seriously suggest Legend of Legaia..
This is one of the best rpgs I've ever played.
It's so underrated that those reviewers should eat shit, and I never really heard anything totally negative about it.
Well, it has cliche plot but don't let that fool you. It's save the world, yea it's not the best story but it's certainly not a bad story actually it's pretty good.
PLease watch this review.. (very little spoiler from the beginnings of the game - shouldn't hurt)
------------------------
-------------------
Also Wild Arms 2.. If you liked other version of WA.
It is also underrated but it's not bad. Actually it's very good.
WA2 has the most mature and theme in all WA ever.(please correct me i haven't played 3-5, but that's what I thinik)
Can't say much, this is my fav RPG of all.
Cliche story but good.. you might wonder how a cliche story can be any good well it doesn't mean the plot is nopt good, the story itself would also be not good.
MUSIC. Best part of it.
----------------
-----------------
Um.. Chrono Cross.
let this review do the talking (no real spoiler that could hurt0)
If anyhing else comes to mind, I'll suggesst it..
Suikoden 2
Legend of MAna
Some other games never played - meaning unpopular but those who have played it, well they should feel lucky!:
Threads of Fate
Jade Cocoon