In agreement with Bojangles, Obscure is a decent alternative. I recently (well, a month ago) bought and completed Obscure II and while it's not "mind fuck" scary, it certainly hearkens back somewhat to the first Resident Evil as far as scares go... just not as many puzzles and a very B-Movie-ish college kids storyline. Ever seen The Faculty? That's the kind of dialogue you can expect from this game, but the monster designs are friggin great. You can make out distinct human features that will freak (if not gross you out) when you realize how the body could have mutated to take on that form. You'll see what I mean as you unlock the game's artwork through play. (and have your first sighting of the crab walking female monster) You can probably get either one for PS2 or Wii for about $15-$20 now.