what, no they aren't.
they're maudlin horseshit lyrics, jesus christ. in fact I can think of no other band that embodies maudlin horseshit lyrics than death cab.
whoops I forgot
four random songs all about I LOVE YOU I WONT FORGET YOU WHEN I FUCK OFF/DIE yes these are some lyrical masterminds here.
Wait, so are you saying they are all about literally "i love you, i wont forget you when i leave/die"?
first song is just a general love song or something. second one is love/we will grow old together some day you will get old and die and i wont be able to live without you etc (also you left out the cooler parts of the lyrics "if heaven and hell decide that they both are satisfied, illuminate the 'no's on their vacancy signs" ok wait though thats the only cool part there are no partS i guess but still!). third one is about losing someone and thinking about the relationships you have, the connections you've made and wondering who is going to be there for you like you are for this person (whoever dies in the song). fourth song is about leaving someone and feeling guilty about not feeling guilty about it.
I never said they were
really out there or
super creative in terms of topic choice-- most of their songs are definitely about love and relationships etc, and all four of them I guess are related to love/loss kinda like you said if you want to boil it down a bit and ignore the details, but at the same time I think some of it is their lyricism is generally more on the clever side. Not saying gibbard is a lyrical genius or the best writer of our generation or whatever the hell
ART BEAUTIFUL DEEP etc but, while I grant his lyrics are maudlin, they certainly aren't "horseshit".