Well...lemme put it this way.
Dooms isn't my FAVORITE rm game of all time, but it does do a pretty good job and stand in my mind a lot. I think because it's different, unlike everyone else who makes the same old thing, this guy challenged everyone and made a much more adult like game...which worked surprisingly. Also! It was one of the first horror games I played that scared me to death for many nights, after playing Dooms 4...I had trouble sleeping that night, it was AWESOME!!! Just the way it was done, felt like I watching one of those cheap horror flicks, and that is why I like the series. I pray everyday that T is working on Dooms 5! It's up there with a couple of my most anticipated, so yes...to most people Dooms may be stupid, gory, and just totally off the wall...but it's that which attracts me to this series.
I always get mad whenever I hear that Dooms 4 one the miaso for worst game. It just makes me so angry...that I could...
well you know.
(If I had my choice however, I would rather play Romancing Walker then Dooms however) ^^