You contradict yourself here seemingly because you think earl is acting a bit superior. If it isn't acceptable or legitimate as a 'lifestyle', then how is a person who does not act like not better than someone who does? The who's better stuff doesn't really matter, you can hate a way of behaving while behaving that way yourself. You are allowed to recognize and criticize bad things and the people who do them and your own status regarding the issue isn't really relevant if you are actually interested in working out what is right and wrong and not in just coming out on top in the argument.
its not a lifestyle to me because I don't consider it something worthy to call a lifestyle. Its something he does on his freetime to entertain him, meet women, and have fun. I hardly think its something he lives by and would shake his life if he went without it. I wouldn't call it "bad" either. No one is coming to any sort of particular harm. I guess you'd say the women are but in my opinion if they choose to accept that and be around men like that, even specifically choose them out. Theres nothing bad about it, its just immature. And my definition of "bad" and "immature" are not the same.
And like I said before about the second paragraph. He isn't going out and yelling obsenities or gross things at some random helpless woman (I'm pretty sure) he's going to a bar and trying to get in their pants. It is base, you're absolutely right about that. But some people look for base things and can accept base things from either gender. You two are acting like he's going out to find some nice helpless girl to fuck the shit out of and make them feel like an empty piece of meat. I don't agree with that perception. I think its two casual people that aren't looking for a legitimate relationship and both have certain base desires they want fullfilled. If thats all they want and they're getting it then who are you to assume that is wrong. Do you actually think that he would be so dumb as to legitimately think women are only good for fucking and when he's looking for a good ol' fuckin' he wants his prime rib in top condition ect ect ect.
No, but he does talk that way and I can see how you get that from his posts. Its a stupid man subculture and he's either going to one day realize its piggish to word what he's trying to say like that or keep doing it but really who cares honestly. Its one of those things that you can point out and hope he notices but if he doesn't or thinks you're being a prude about its just a waste of time to keep going on about it like you're ever enlightened.
Do you really want to be saying we should abandon feminism as a starting point for the way we treat women in society because there are a few, allegedly, who like their men to treat them like bedpost notches and possessions? There is a reason feminism is rooted deep in people's head, and it's a good things. It's because it is right. It's not something so flimsy that it can't stand under the pressure of some superficial asshole saying 'heh, come on. humanity is a toilet anyway...'. If you are actually interested in arguing about this, feminism wins. You keep bringing up this notion that people should shut up about it because nobody is perfect but why is that even relevant? Bled may be the person getting the heat for it now but it's all the ideas behind what he's saying that are objectionable. I think this whole WELL WHO ARE YOU TO SAY crap is lazy and irrelevant.
Don't treat women like objects, don't act like masculinity is something you have over women. These are good rules.
Nope, but you guys (you two especially) bring it up every chance you get like its something we aren't all already fully aware of and realize. I actually think feminism is very important but I also think its important to realize that lots and lots of other people don't think or want to think about sex and gender relationships so deeply. Some people are just fucking shallow or like to be shallow for a period of time, that doesn't mean that at some point in the past, present, or future they won't come to realize its importance. They just do not fucking care and like refusing to eat meat or protesting war or anything else of philisophical importance to you, some people just don't live that way and you can point your opinions out to them and hope they see it your way but if they don't then you don't have to look down on them for it, thats hypocritical in my opinion.